History, Evolution, and The Darwin Debate

Darwiniana header image 2

Learning, passive, self-propelled

February 14th, 2015 · 1 Comment

These issues of math ability are a source of head shaking for me when I read about them as here. I had strong linguistic skills but was bored by math and dropped it my senior year in high school. Doing classics in college encountered the realm of pop science/math books and I was intrigued by a heuristic text on calculus and Newton (by a ‘Kline’, his book was once popular, Booyer, A History of Calculus, but the recent Calculus Wars may be the best here?) and one on the calculus wars of Newton and Leibnitz (not the later book by that name). The enigma of differentials seemed amazing. This so intrigued me that I signed up for a course in calculus. To do that I had to review high school math and trigonometry. I was amazed to see how easy that was and that took about a week. From there I taught myself a lot of math by myself and the physics that went with it up through vector analysis for electromag-, tensor analysis for relativity, as I then began to phase out slightly. String theory I never reached. In the peace corps I ended up teaching physics to A level students. with no course in physics. I had learned how to learn, and that in my case came with a degree of maturity that was post-adolescent.

The point was obvious that judgements of teenagers on math are worse than misleading, they lobotomize students, one reason being the crushing blow of doing poorly in a subject. It was clear to me that for some reason self-teaching was a thousand times better than passive learning. No way around it. So the moral is to never prejudge students. The way to reform teaching is elusive, but the subject of high school math is so ‘easy’ objectively that failure to learn is largely the result of the school situation. In a future culture learning should be taken for granted and not produce the casualties now so unfairly judged over idiot questions like high school algebra.

The book must have from a Morris Kline, 1959, Mathematics and the Physical World.

Tags: General

1 response so far ↓

  • 1 NK // Feb 16, 2015 at 7:58 am

    Frankly, there is no great secret about what has happened. The pursuit of knowledge to understand man’s place in the universe (I.e. the grand philosophical questions that really drive people) has been infected by the ethos of mechanistic capitalism. Now, the underlying purpose of education is just to make people cogs in a machine to perpetuate shallow money making schemes. We live in the Weberian Iron Cage:

    Gone are the romantic days of a teacher/student relationships like Socrates and Plato. We have education factories where the sole purpose is processing not educating. Education has become bureaucratic.
    This is a mere microcosm of modern society. Wertrational (wert=”value”) has been superceded by zweckrational (zweck=”aim, goal, purpose”). Goal-oriented thinking has undermined the very soul of society. Weber’s pessimistic view of the transition of modern society has been realized. As compared to the Enlightenment this is certainly a time of the “polar night of icy darkness”.


Leave a Comment